Again, this is a band that followed me on
Twitter, leading me to follow and listen to them. Initially I thought they were
fine, but they weren’t making much of an impression on me, and then I had a
very bad reaction to their video for “Silent Night”.
What’s odd to me now is that I can’t find the
video at all. It’s not on their own site or Youtube. I may not have looked hard
enough, but I remember seeing a lot of compliments tweeted about it.
I am going to try and see if I can explain
what bothered me about the video, and then connect that with how the band does
not work for me.
First of all, their performance of the song
is completely fine. I have listened to it a few times via Spotify as I have
been preparing to write this. From a vocal and instrumental point of view, the
band is fine.
The video shows a girl whose father is
disabled, which embarrasses her, and she acts out at school and he is
continuously supportive, and then, and I could be getting parts of this wrong,
she tries to kill herself, and he donates his blood for that, and she lives and
he dies. Merry Christmas!
Granted, for that song, an allegory for a
father’s sacrificial love, and ungrateful children, may be appropriate, but it
was just kind of ugly. It felt horrible and depressing, and beyond that it felt
shamelessly manipulative. And yes, I totally cried. That was the intent, and it
succeeded, but it felt too manufactured and I resented it. Again, a lot of
people loved it.
So, how does this relate to the band as a
whole? I think my real issue is some artificiality, and I believe the reason
for that is that they are trying to convey a depth and a meaning that they do
not really feel. I would also say that about “Our Excuse”, one of the tracks
from their album.
I don’t mean to imply that the band has no
depth, but I do feel they lack a strong sense of identity. There is an
unevenness of tone and sound. It’s not that a band can’t do a lot of
experimenting and still be them, but ultimately it doesn’t matter how many
times I have listened, I have no grip on who Bonaventure is.
I would say that my two favorites are “These
Shoes” and “Tiny Fraction”, but I could totally believe that they were by
different bands. Some songs sound a little bit like there is is a Irish pub
influence (ala Mumford and Sons), like “The Forgotten Waltz”, and some songs are very techno, like
“Restless”, and it is interesting that they suddenly go French in “Charmant
Paysage”, but it is all disjointed. Interesting riffs appear, and then don’t
necessarily feel of a piece with the rest of the song.
Now, identities can be found. On their web
site there is a new video “I Dare You” that was not on Spotify, and it seems to
be heading in the right direction. The video itself conveys a mood without
really getting anywhere, but that doesn’t mean the band won’t. So, a little
disappointing, but there’s potential, and I hope they realize it.
No comments:
Post a Comment