Here's a tangent on the way to my post.
When caring for my mother was at its hardest, my respite was usually going to movies. I have this list of movies I saw then, where I had thoughts but never wrote about them. I was not able to blog much then.
Whether I ever get to the rest or not, here is one:
Dunkirk (2017)
It wasn't from the movie itself, but from the articles that were coming out about the subject matter.
What they were saying is that there is this collective English memory of the country's WWII experience as the stiff upper lip and "Keep calm and carry on", but in fact the majority of the people were very against involvement initially.
A large part of that change in mindset is due to Winston Churchill and how he framed his speeches, essentially telling the people how brave and patriotic and good they were more than how good they needed to be.
For some perspective, the United Kingdom and France combined declaration of war on Nazi Germany was September 3rd, 1939, in response to the invasion of Poland.
The Dunkirk evacuations took place from May 26th through June 4th, 1940, with June 4th also being the day of Churchill's "We will fight on the beaches... " speech.
July of 1940 is when people really started turning on Chamberlain; at least it was becoming more public.
A lot of that was feeling that they were inadequately prepared for war by his actions. Maybe part of the shift was an acceptance that the war was happening -- maybe it had been inevitable -- so that's why you carry on with the stiff upper lip.
They really didn't give a lot of details on that, but what stuck with me at the time was that a narrative gets shaped, and that is what people remember. Stories are easier to remember, but also, history is written by the victors.
That tangent brings me to what I wanted to get to.
It started with In Defense of Witches by Mona Chollet.
It wasn't my favorite of the relevant books, but one point it made pretty clear was that we think of witch trials as part of the Dark Ages, but they came after that, related to Renaissance and Enlightenment and all of that growing modernization.
Much of it was due to economic competition, as men moved into industries typically dominated by women. Some of it was just about control.
Somehow, "enlightenment" -- such as it was -- came with some serious misogyny.
This was reinforced by The Death of Nature: Women, Ecology, and the Scientific Revolution by Carolyn Merchant, but it was especially important in Caliban and the Witch: Women, the Body, and Primitive Accumulation by Silvia Federici.
What is more, you can see that it wasn't always that way.
It sent me to another book that had been on my reading list for a long time: The Year 1000: What Life Was Like at the Turn of the First Millennium, An Englishman's World by Robert Lacey and Danny Danziger.
There is so much that we get wrong.
You might think... Dark Ages; life is "nasty, brutish, and short", right?
Well, that was written by someone in the 17th century. Yes, life could be hard earlier and there were lean times, but there was a calendar that allowed for many holidays and there were resources in the commons, and there are ways in which moving forward was not progress.
Then there was this article:
Women had more contributions and more power than we readily acknowledge.
How did that happen? Men's increased repression was very successful. Then they got to convey the mindset that supported them.
Shockingly, the other changes happening at that time led to a consolidation in wealth and unequal changes in the standard of living, even among men. I suspect this is not a coincidence.
Here's the thing that is so important about it -- and Federici's book is the one I recommend the most -- when we don't look at what is happening with women, we don't truly understand what is happening with the men.
Let me add more to that: inasmuch as there is a dominant race, focusing on them where the oppression of other people goes unnoticed, will eventually spread up to that dominant race. It sure doesn't start at the top top.
There is so much that could be mined here, but this is a long post.
I believe this topic will be revisited (and I hope to spend some time on artifacts that male archeologists could not figure out until they got a woman's input), but first I am going to spend some time writing about music.
Related posts:
https://sporkful.blogspot.com/2025/03/spooky-season-witches.html