While most of the books did not have "witch" in the title, it was still something that came up.
First of all, there was some fiction that was not great.
The best of those was The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches by Sangu Mandanna.
I saw it on a library post for the Shameless Romance Book Club.
That in itself would tend to put me off, but I decided to go for it. It was at times too cute and I was amazed at how awkward the unnecessary sex scene was, but I didn't hate it; that was a win.
In this world, witches are born and have to learn how to use their power. Fear often gets in the way of connection. I thought the relationships in that area were handled well.
With Spells For Forgetting by Adrienne Young, I believe I saw that someone else read it and was curious about the mystery. That resolution was actually pretty satisfying, except that you have some people who don't seem to be unusually evil doing some pretty twisted things, while other people who should be really motivated just let things go for years.
I could have liked the book more if the people were more compelling.
The better fiction was The Heretic's Daughter by Kathleen Kent, from my Daughters list.
I kept getting it confused in my mind with Gallileo's Daughter, also on that list, but about a different heretic.
This is based on the story of Martha Carrier, executed during the Salem Witch Trials and written by one of her actual descendants. While a fictionalized account, it draws from a fascinating family history.
Relationships are hard here, as is life, but you can appreciate the struggles and the choices.
Then there was a non-fiction book that was not great, but it led me to a book that was amazing:
In Defense of Witches:The Legacy of the Witch Hunts and Why Women Are Still on Trial by Mona Challet
There are good points, but then there are attempts to be cute. Some of it could be the translation.
The premise of looking at the types of women accused of witchcraft and why was interesting, but another reviewer wrote that all of the good points were in the introduction. Well, the introduction was written by Carmen Maria Machado.
However, in reading In Defense of Witches -- and reading about it -- there kept being references to Caliban and the Witch: Women, the Body, and Primitive Accumulation by Silvia Federici.
The funny thing about that was that it was already on my larger to-read list. It did come up with the word searches, but since it seemed to be more statistical I was going to hold off on it. The various references convince me otherwise.
There is so much in Federici's writing that is interesting and that points to other things to study.
The title is a reference to Caliban from The Tempest and his mother, whom is referenced in the play, but not seen.
The play was written at a time when slavery was expanding, along with persecution of "witches". That becomes the theme of what was going on in society, largely driven by the rise of capitalism.
That actually led me to yet another book (which wasn't as good), but that kind of becomes something else.
We will get there, but I will take one more week to wrap up Spooky Season.