Some time ago I came across an article that led to another article that sent me in pursuit of different comics.
"The most underrated comics, according to Goodreads"
https://bookriot.com/most-underrated-comics-according-to-goodreads/?utm_source=pocket-newtab-en-us
"The best graphic novels you've never heard of"
https://bookriot.com/underrated-graphic-novels/
As you can see, both articles were written by Rachel Brittain and came courtesy of BookRiot. They tend to be more enthusiastic than I am about things, but I don't hold it against them.
At the time, reading the articles did not require a subscription. That could have saved me a lot of time. (I might hold the subscription requirement against them.)
I'm not saying that I regret reading these comics, exactly, but a lot of them sure weren't that good. Maybe it's me.
Without being able to refer to the articles (I'm not going to pay for bad advice), I may have missed some or gotten some mixed up, but this is what I've got.
I hated these most of all
Heavy Vinyl by Carly Usdin
Rocket Salvage by Yehudi Mercado
Godshaper by Simon Spurrier
Vagrant Queen by Magdalene Visaggio
The Heart Hunter by Mickey George
The Many Deaths of Laila Starr by Ram V
Welcome Back by Christopher Sebela
and also...
Crowded by Christopher Sebela
If the whole premise is built on keeping someone alive whom everyone is trying to kill, but the target is so obnoxious you kind of want her dead...Mainly when I hated them it was for a lot of bad attitude and noise (sometimes being pretentious instead) but without a core humanity. That was more true of Crowded than any of the others and there was some competition.
Too much world-building, not enough interesting happening in the world.
The Witch Owl Parliament by David Bowles
M.F.K.: Book One by Nilah Magruder
Isola by Brenden Fletcher
Prism Stalker by Sloane Leong
What is the point, exactly?
I See A Knight by Xulia Vicente
This one didn't even build the world; there were so many more questions than answers. That can be fine, but I don't think they were even great questions.
Kind of meh or maybe weird
Fun Fun Fun World by Yehudi Mercado
Catboy by Benji Nate
Cosmic Pizza Party by Nick Murphy
The last one is really meant for children. I believe the inclusion was to try and represent more ages, but I don't think it works for adults.
At least some interesting ideas
Afar by Leila del Duca
Djeliya: A West African Fantasy Epic by Juni Ba
Eve by Victor Lavalle
Ronin Island by Greg Pak
Mech Cadets by Greg Pak
FTL, Y'All: Tales From the Age of the $200 Warp Drive by multiple contributors
The Black Bull of Norroway by Cat Seaton
The last one is inspired by a fairy tale I had not previously known, but I accidentally checked that out first.
The weirdest
Meal by Blue Delliquanti
This is literally trying to sell everyone on eating insects and how elegant and delicious that can be.
My favorites
Umma's Table by Yeon-Sik Hong
Lifetime Passes by Terry Blas
School for ExtraTerrestrial Girls: Girl on Fire by Jeremy Whitley
Everyday Hero Machine Boy by Irma Kniivila
Those last four could not have less in common with each other. Well, maybe the last two have some similarities in terms of young people dealing with space stuff, but even with that they are very different.
Perhaps the real key is that I am likely to hate stuff by Christopher Sebela and appreciate work by Greg Pak.
I focused on authors because those were the issues. There may have been art I liked more or less than others, but the issue was the story or lack thereof. Isola was clearly making an effort to be visually lush, which may be why there wasn't any room for storytelling.
It can work that if you like one thing by an author that you will like other things by them, but it's not a hard and fast rule. Besides, sometimes you need to try new things.
Reconstructing this list, I remembered many comics that someone recommended and then I hated, but there were also so many that I really liked.
You don't know if you don't try.
One of the nice things about graphic novels is that you can try them out a bit more quickly than more non-graphic books.