Based on
the people I follow on Twitter, I come across a lot of content that deals with
racism that I would probably not otherwise see as a white person in the
suburbs. One of those recent discoveries was the Brown In PDX Tumblr page. Reading over it was horrible in general,
but this was the entry that made yesterday's post necessary:
I feel a
need to dissect this a little.
First of
all, Asia is big. We kind of covered that
yesterday with some of the differences between Korean and Lao food. To be fair,
they are not exactly neighbors. Vientiane and Seoul are about 3000 miles apart, so you
should expect some differences.
I have
heard some people talk about Northern versus Southern cuisine in India, and
even people who don't eat a lot of Chinese food often recognize that there are
some differences between Szechuan and Cantonese food. And Laos is not a particularly large
country, but without me ever going there, and only interacting with the refugee
population in two California cities, I still met people from at
least three different mountain tribes. There were similarities, but there were
also differences in food, language, and clothing.
I can only
assume the woman in the story, when she lived in Asia, did not specifically live in Thailand, because surely then she would have
said that, but what does she think Asia means? Let's even take out the Indian subcontinent and
Russia (because it dips its toe in Europe), and the Middle East for no good
reason, and still do you think that living in Mongolia would tell you what it's
like to live in Malaysia? Shouldn't living abroad have made you less ignorant?
Okay, she
was on shaky ground anyway. First of all, requesting things not on the menu
your first time at a restaurant is questionable, and if you must do it at least
leave the attitude behind.
Also, it is
very questionable to use the term "you people". There are situations
where it works. If I enter my work environment and find that my coworkers are standing
around looking guilty in a sea of feathers and straw, I might reasonably say,
especially if I have some managerial capacity, "You people have some
explaining to do!"
On the
other hand, if I am using "you people" to educate you about what
foods you like, or what kind of characteristics you have, based on skin color
that I have in fact mis-characterized because while the waitress did list Asian
as a part of her heritage she also listed black and Caribbean, I am leaving
myself open to criticism. I can see where employment in the Thai restaurant
might seem like a context clue, but you think the largest continent on the
planet is monolithic in its cuisine, so you lose all the points! Idiot! It
would make more sense to walk into a French restaurant and insist that they
make you a pizza in the name of Catherine de' Medici.
Incidentally,
I think half the cooks at the Mongolian grill (which we all accept as not truly
being characteristic of Mongolian food, but still tasting good) are Mexican,
because one of them lived near our neighborhood. Actually, we had a next-door
neighbor who was from Mexico but worked at an Indian restaurant
too, so workplace is not a great predictor of heritage or ethnicity.
I believe
tomorrow I will write a bit more about how we get people who feel so
comfortable proclaiming their ignorance, and especially how we get them in Portland.
For now I
will go back to my opening of yesterday, where Asian food makes me think
"Yum!" That is pretty much true, because for me it means papaya salad
and egg rolls and nasi goreng and Mongolian beef and pot stickers and bento and
hom bao and a lot of different things that I like a lot. At the same time, Asian
food includes sushi. With my combined aversions to fish, cucumber, and avocado,
I do not love sushi. Asian food also includes a lot of foods that I have never
tried, some of which I would probably love and others not.
(And the
only thing I really remember seeing baby corn in was a dish of happy family
that's claim to fame was including eight different vegetables. Adding it may
have been a matter of running up the numbers, unless someone can use the baby
corn clue to figure out what country that woman lived in.)
The continent
of Asia includes mountains, hills, jungles,
steppes, coastlines of oceans and rivers; of course there are lots of different
foods. There are also different types of homes and jobs and modes of transportation.
This could be said about even the smallest continent because there are some
strong regional differences in Australia.
If you can
accept that there are a lot of things that you don't know, and just enjoy the
variety, that complexity is great. If you always feel like you know better than
anyone else and need to show it, well, the world is the same size, but it's
going to seem a lot smaller.
No comments:
Post a Comment