Friday, June 09, 2017

Band Review: Eduardo Slompo


Eduardo Slompo has a Youtube channel and is based in Sidney.

Offerings on the channel include live recording sessions, a cappella mash-ups, and one man band performances recorded separately and combined. With well over one hundred videos, he shows a fairly impressive ability with multiple instruments and styles. There is talent and skill.

At the same time, reviewing them all together gets a bit boring. I believe the preferred model would be to subscribe and then watch new videos as they go up.

I thought that the mash-ups might be a way of breaking out of the routine, creating interesting arrangements of songs you might not expect to go together. Instead, they tend to shove many opening lines into a small time frame. That was most obvious with the Beatles, but most disappointing on the Queen mash-up.

It could have made so much sense to instead do a one-man band version of "Bohemian Rhapsody", or maybe a focused mash-up of "Bohemian Rhapsody" with one or two others of their more dramatic songs: "I Want to Break Free"? There are so many ways you could go there.

I have previously criticized other bands for relying too much on covers without creating their own music. In a case like this, covers can make sense, but there should still be a place for personal creative vision, and the lack of that is felt here.



No comments: